Oh, St. Augustine. You would, in fact, be my favorite city in all of Florida if it weren't for things like your Catholic churches having large fake grave markers that litter your entire front and back lawns with a sign that says, "CEMETERY OF INNOCENTS: in memory of every child that dies from abortion" along with multiple billboards condemning women's rights surrounding your otherwise beautiful town.
As it stands, Key Largo is beating you out by just a smidgen. Have more of those spicy tea shops and Spanish bakeries and we'll talk.